Ok, so I thought I’d be done posting about Germany, but I
keep remembering so many good things I learned that need to be shared. I guess
this discussion works for American movies brought to Europe in general.
I do not think I need to explain that many English films get
dubbed when they go abroad (not all though, many just have subtitles). Well,
since I typically do not understand the dubbing I just watch and laugh because
it sounds funnier in another language, and in the case of a piece of crap film
like Twilight, the French version was actually better because the
actors/ACTRESS actually had some emotion in their voices (see note below on why
I was watching Twilight).
Anyway, John the German and I were discussing the Die Hard films on day
and he dropped this phrase on me: “Yippie Yah Yei Schweinebacke!” I asked him
to repeat it and I said, “Ha! It rhymes!” He was confused because those phrases
obviously do not rhyme, but then I explained the English version. I needed to know,
“What does ‘Schweinebacke’ mean?” Turns out, this traditional German insult
means “pig cheek.” This led to a good long laugh for me. I am not sure exactly
why this translation tickled my fancy so much. Perhaps it was the good fortune
that there is actually a phrase in German that mimics the sound of the English
version,
or that the insult is strange, or that it just seems so
innocent compared to the much more offensive English phrase. Oh! On a side
note, there is a funny site called “Thumbs and Ammo” where they photo-shopped
the guns out of scenes from action films and replaced them with a thumbs-up!
Some are pretty hilarious and inspired me to make this gem combining the German
phrase and one of their images.
Die Hard, rated G for all ages! |
In addition to movies being dubbed, the titles are often
changed. Sometimes it is a literal translation into the other language, or they
are changed and added to. Brokeback Mountain, for example, becomes Le Secret de
Brokeback Mountain. In other cases they keep the title in English, but change the
phrase. I have not found a good explanation for why they do this exactly. It
seems that the titles which receive this treatment might simply be difficult to
translate or they do not have an equivalent word in that language. For example,
Step Up became Sexy Dance and The Hangover became Very Bad Trip (it seems crazy
the French do not have a word for ‘hangover,’ instead they say someone had ‘too
much wine’).
Hopefully this was not overly boring for those of you who
are not into films. As a movie lover, and I suppose as an anthropologist, I
find it fascinating to see which aspects of films and movie culture are
exported and modified to fit a different culture. The best part is, there is
always something new to discover or learn about this because there are always
new TV shows and films entering the movie world!
**Oh! And as for watching Twilight. This was two years ago,
I believe, when I was staying with a friend in Dijon. She had to work for the
day and I wanted to practice listening to French. I looked at her movie
collection and thought, “Which of these is going to have a simple story line
and basic dialogue which I may be able to understand…” Well, it proved to be
that one! The funniest part was that after about an hour and a half of
listening to and reading subtitles in the French, I became tired and switched
back to English. I regretted it immediately. My god, the French made the film
bearable because the actors actually had some feeling in their voices, but the
original film…my god…how on earth were they allowed to make four of these
movies?**